Live Q&A: Practice Chanters vs. Bagpipe Chanters Explained & A New Exercise Master Your Top Hand - BagpipeLessons.com
▶ Video lessonBeginner questionsJori Chisholm, BagpipeLessons.com. Updated August 1, 2024

Live Q&A: Practice Chanters vs. Bagpipe Chanters Explained & A New Exercise Master Your Top Hand

A practice chanter is a quiet, buzzy instrument with small holes, a plastic reed and a straight bore, where you learn your fingering. A pipe chanter has bigger holes, a cane reed and a conical bore, so it is much louder and brighter. You cannot use a pipe chanter as a practice chanter. I also show the Twist Trap Practice Pipes and a new top hand exercise.

The Main Ideas

I get this question a lot through my website: what is the difference between a practice chanter and a bagpipe chanter? In this live Q&A I show you both side by side, so you can see the holes, the reeds and the bore.

The short answer is that the practice chanter is a quiet, buzzy instrument where you learn your fingering. The pipe chanter has bigger holes, a cane reed and a conical bore, which gives that big, bright sound. And no, you cannot use a pipe chanter as a practice chanter.

I also show the R.G. Hardie Twist Trap Practice Pipes, and a new top hand exercise for your weakest finger, the ring finger.

At a glance

Practice chanterSmall holes, plastic reed, straight bore, low and buzzy sound
Pipe chanterBigger holes, cane reed, conical bore, loud and bright sound
Pipe chanter as practice chanter?No. Too loud, and you have to blow too hard
ReedsPlastic on the practice chanter, cane on the pipe chanter
Twist Trap Practice PipesTwo drones and a chanter that also works as a practice chanter
Top hand exerciseBuilds a soft touch in your weakest finger, the left ring finger

Video highlights

“No, you cannot use a pipe chanter as a practice chanter.”
“This is the Infinity pipe chanter from R.G. Hardie. This is my favorite bagpipe chanter.”
“Remember the two pillars of good form: keep your hands soft and keep the fingers in nice and close to the chanter.”
“So zero maintenance, cool sound, so these are the R.G. Hardie Twist Trap Practice Pipes.”
Learn the Pipes Right
Free guideLearn the Pipes RightA free guide to getting started on the practice chanter the right way, so your first steps lead to the pipes.
Get the free guide

The gear in this video

Your questions, answered

Tap a time to watch that part of the video.

What do the drones and the chanter do on the bagpipes?

The drones sit up on your shoulder and make the background hum that gives the pipes their distinctive sound. The main melody comes out of the pipe chanter, which is out in front of you and has the holes you raise and lower your fingers on.

What is a practice chanter?

It's the practice instrument you start on if you want to get started on the pipes. It has a bottom part where the fingers go and a top part you blow into, and the top covers the reed without touching it. Most practice chanter reeds are plastic these days.

Why should I start on a practice chanter before the pipes?

The holes are small, and they're countersunk, which means slightly wider at the top so they're easier to feel. That's where you learn your fingering, reading music, rhythm and tapping your foot. I recommend learning a handful of pipe tunes so you're not starting from scratch when you move to the pipes.

Why are the holes on a bagpipe chanter so much bigger?

It has to do with the sound you're trying to produce. On my favorite chanter, the Infinity, I can fit my pinky all the way into the low G hole. The pipe chanter reed is cane, which gives that really bright, projecting, crisp sound.

How does a practice chanter sound compared to a pipe chanter?

The pipe chanter is really loud and takes a lot more pressure and volume. The practice chanter has a low-pitched, buzzy, warm sound. It's a practice instrument, not a performance instrument.

What is a conical bore, and how is it different from a practice chanter?

The pipe chanter is a cone: really narrow at the top and quite wide at the bottom. The practice chanter has a straight bore, a bit wider than a tube of spaghetti all the way down. That's why the practice chanter holes are all about the same size and the pipe chanter holes get bigger as you go down.

Can I use a bagpipe chanter as a practice chanter?

No. It doesn't work. You wouldn't want to, because it's way too loud and you have to blow way too hard. It also doesn't do what a practice instrument should: be easy to blow, quiet and comfortable so you can focus on your fingering.

What are the Twist Trap Practice Pipes?

R.G. Hardie's set with a blowpipe, a chanter, a bag and two drones. The practice chanter top has a little water trap you twist open that catches spit and condensed moisture from your breath, so it stays off your reed.

Can the Twist Trap chanter work as a practice chanter?

Yes. The chanter that comes with the pipes can be taken apart, and the top and bottom go together as a practice chanter. People hoped to do that with their Infinity pipe chanter, which doesn't work, but with the Twist Trap Practice Pipes it does.

Are the Twist Trap pipes good for playing with other instruments?

They have a good pitch for it, a nice lower pitch that is in tune with concert pitch, so they work with fiddle, guitar or piano. The volume is better too, and it has one common stock for both drones.

Why do the bagpipes have a bag?

Two reasons. It lets you have several reeds plugged in while you only put the blowpipe in your mouth. And it's an air reserve and a buffer, so you can have a continuous sound while you take a breath, as long as you keep the right pressure with your arm.

Which finger is the weakest on the top hand?

Your ring fingers are your least coordinated fingers, and your non-dominant hand is the weakest of the two. For most right-handed players, that makes the left-hand ring finger the weakest one.

How do I keep my top hand relaxed when I play?

Remember the two pillars of good form: keep your hands soft and keep the fingers in close to the chanter. Don't be hard, stiff or squeezing, and don't raise the fingers super high. I use the natural bounciness of my finger, not slamming it down.

How do I take the top hand exercise from the chanter to the pipes?

Practice it on the chanter first, then transfer it to your pipes. Use your shoulder and upper back muscles to squeeze the bag and keep your bicep relaxed, so your forearm, wrist and hand can stay relaxed.

Each week, the Inner Circle's lively sessions are designed to benefit pipers of all skill levels, all around the world.

LEARN FASTER. FIND GREATER ENJOYMENT FROM YOUR PIPING. JOIN ME.

Join the Inner Circle

Full video transcript

My exact words from the video, lightly cleaned up for reading. Click any time to jump the video to that moment.

Jori Chisholm, founder of BagpipeLessons.com
About Jori Chisholm

Jori started BagpipeLessons.com in 1999, and in 2003 he became the first piper to teach one-on-one lessons by video. His online teaching has been featured on the front page of the New York Times, and thousands of pipers around the world have used his lessons, tools and products.

He is a four-time U.S. Gold Medalist for Piping, has won prizes at the Argyllshire Gathering, the Northern Meeting, Cowal and Braemar, and won the World Pipe Band Championships three times with the Simon Fraser University Pipe Band. He invented the Tone Protector, the InTune Mic and the Endurance Practice Chanter, and in 2011 he founded the World Online Piping & Drumming Championships.

More about Jori →
Jori Chisholm holding a practice chanter
The Inner Circle

Ready to take your piping further?

Get unlimited access to 790+ lessons, videos and tunes, plus a live Zoom class with me every week. Every replay is searchable to the exact moment anything was taught.

$399/year works out to $33.25 a month$45/month month to month
For pipe bandsBring your whole band into the Inner Circle Every piper gets their own login, and we start with a band coaching session on Zoom with me to map out your season. From $10 per piper per month.See band memberships →
Free: Learn the Pipes RightGet it