
Bagpipe Q&A: Essential Gear, Playing with Good Form, Winning the Worlds, John D. Burgess, and more!
The Main Ideas
In this live Q&A I answer what a piper really needs for a first set of pipes, from the bare essentials to the extras that make piping easier. I go through the gear I recommend, like the Tone Protector, the Dri-flo, brushes, the InTune Mic and the Bagpipe Gauge, and why.
Then we get into the bigger questions: how to find the time and motivation to practice, why soft hands and low fingers are the two pillars of good form, what we can learn from John D. Burgess, and why you should not expect to play better under pressure.
At the end I explain what piobaireachd is and which tunes to start with.
At a glance
| Format | A live Q&A on YouTube, about an hour |
|---|---|
| Bare essentials | Pipes, pipe chanter, drone reeds, chanter reed, bag and drone cords |
| Gear I recommend | Tone Protector, Dri-flo, reed case, hemp, tuning toolkit, brushes, InTune Mic, Bagpipe Gauge |
| Gauge green zone | Between 25 and 35 inches of water, with 30 in the middle |
| Two pillars of good form | Soft hands and low fingers |
| First piobaireachd tunes | The Munro's Salute and The Little Spree |
Video highlights
“You want to have soft hands on the chanter.”
“Your pipes should be easy for you. That’s the secret.”
“The tuner eliminates the need to rely on your ear.”
“If you are in a competition scenario, you should not expect that you’re going to do better when it really matters.”
The gear and tunes in this video
R.G. Hardie Poly BagpipesPrecision-made, cost-effective and easy to maintain, in high-strength acetal (poly) plastic with an AdjustiStick blowpipe and a 5-year guarantee.Learn more →
Tone Protector Chanter CapThe world's first digital chanter cap with two-way humidity control, for a steadier reed and less warm-up time.Learn more →
Tone Protector Reed CaseDigital reed storage with two-way humidity control, so your backup chanter reeds stay ready to play.Learn more →
Dri-Flo Moisture Control SystemBannatyne's moisture control system: three tubes of silica gel that dry the air inside your bag.Learn more →
Precision Tuning Tool KitProfessional-grade tools for fine-tuning your chanter reed, so your pipes play well and stay in tune.Learn more →
Perfect Angle Blowpipe PositionerHolds your blowpipe at the perfect angle for better posture, stamina and comfort.Learn more →
Cloth Bagpipe BrushesA set of four cloth brushes for swabbing out moisture after playing, suitable for drones, chanters, stocks and blowpipes.Learn more →
InTune MicThe world's first wireless clip-on instrument mic for smartphones, for accurate tuning with your favorite app.Learn more →
Bagpipe GaugePlugs into a drone so you can see your bag pressure and learn to blow strong and steady.Learn more →
The Munro's SaluteA reasonably short piobaireachd with a ground and three variations. A great tune to learn as your first piobaireachd.Learn more →
The Little SpreeA commonly heard tune in piobaireachd competitions, one of the three Spree tunes.Learn more →Your questions, answered
Tap a time to watch that part of the video.
What do I need to buy with my first set of pipes?
For the absolute bare essentials, you need pipes. Sticks Only is the three drones, the blowpipe and five stocks. The Basics add a pipe chanter, drone reeds, a pipe chanter reed, a pipe bag and drone cords. That is the absolute minimum for a set of pipes that is playable.
What gear do I need besides the basics?
I recommend a chanter cap, the Tone Protector (my humidity controlling chanter cap and best selling product), and a moisture control system, my favorite being the Dri-flo. Also get the Tone Protector Reed Case for backup reeds, a roll of waxed hemp, brushes, and my Precision Tuning Toolkit.
What is in the Precision Tuning Toolkit?
The Piper's Ultimate Reed Poker for opening up reeds that get too easy, elastic bridles for reeds that get too hard, a roll of black tuning tape pre-cut to half inch width, and a sanding pad for freeing up the blades of a reed.
What does the Perfect Angle Blowpipe Positioner do?
It's a system of adjustable straps that attaches to your drone stocks and your chanter stock, so you can angle the blowpipe to the right position for your mouth. It keeps the blowpipe where you want it, so you don't have to bite down on it, and you can release your teeth when you take a breath.
How does the InTune Mic help me tune?
It's a wireless instrument microphone for your smartphone. The clip-on mic lets you use powerful tuning apps on your phone to tune your drones and chanter really fast, with great precision. You can tune in a noisy place like a pipe band, because the mic sits right next to what you're tuning.
How does the Bagpipe Gauge help me blow steadier?
It plugs into one of your drones and measures and displays the pressure inside your pipes. How much it moves shows how steady you are. The green zone is around 30 inches of water, and I'd say 99% of pipers are between 25 and 35.
How do I find the time and motivation to practice?
Think about why you love piping and what inspired you in the first place. Or skip that and just commit: for example, practice four times a week, no more than two days off in a row, for the next month. If you schedule a short session, you're more likely to do it, and often you'll want to keep going.
What was the hardest thing for you when you learned to play?
The bottom hand and the thumb. In my first or second lesson I had pain in my thumb muscle on the bottom hand, which is very common. Part of it was holding the chanter at a strange angle. Keep your forearms in a neutral position and your hands as soft as you can.
What are the two pillars of good form?
Soft hands, using the absolute minimum pressure needed to cover the holes, and fingers kept low. On short notes your fingers have to be really close to the chanter, because you can't play quick 16th and 32nd notes and cut them if you lift your fingers high.
What can I learn from watching John D. Burgess?
He was an absolutely fantastic player and a real character who won the gold medal in Scotland at age 16. In a video of him playing, the drones don't move, everything is still and his fingers hardly come off the chanter. It looks easy because it is easy for him.
How can I play well when there are so many things to think about?
Practice each skill properly, with enough reps that it becomes automatic. Motor skills go from thinking about every step, to a stage in between, to the autonomous stage where they happen on their own. Work on blowing, birls and memorization separately so they do the right thing even when your attention is elsewhere.
How do I get pipes that are easy to play?
Everything has to be right: the sizing of the blowpipe and bag, good drones and drone reeds, and a pipe chanter reed with the right moisture and strength, kept in the Tone Protector. And you have to be in shape. For more, watch my video called "Why Are My Pipes So Hard?"
Will I play better under pressure in a competition?
Don't expect to. In a book about NBA statistics, no player was better under pressure, the great players were the same, and most people got worse. If you want to do well when it really matters, you need to be doing well in the days, weeks and months leading up to it.
What is piobaireachd?
It's a Gaelic word that literally means bagpipe music. The tunes are long, from five or seven minutes up to 20 or 25. They have a theme, which is slow and full of nuanced phrasing and expression, and then variations on the same basic melody.
Which piobaireachd tunes should I learn first?
The first tunes I usually teach are The Munro's Salute and The Little Spree. I have both as tune lesson downloads in my shop, with the sheet music, a recording of me playing the tune and a recorded lesson of me talking through it.
Each week, the Inner Circle's lively sessions are designed to benefit pipers of all skill levels, all around the world.
LEARN FASTER. FIND GREATER ENJOYMENT FROM YOUR PIPING. JOIN ME.
Join the Inner CircleFull video transcript
Hey, everybody. We’re live. Thanks for coming. Welcome back. My name is Jori Chisholm as you probably know, from BagpipeLessons.com. I have been doing these fun YouTube lives over the last few months. They’ve been really great. More and more people are tuning in and this is your chance to ask me a question live and I answer some of the questions that I get through my website and through my social media channel. So if you are joining live or if you’re on the replay, just put in the comments your name, and where you’re from, how long you’ve been piping and we’ll get into it.
So I see Officer Snap is with us again and we also have Mark Lamont. So guys, just put in the chat where you’re from and a little bit about yourself and if you’ve got any questions in there. So the first question from Officer Snap says, “When purchasing your first set of pipes, what tools and accessories would you say are necessary, almost necessary and just good to have on hand?”
That’s a great question. So when I set up pipes for students or for people who reach out to me through BagpipeLessons.com, I give different options. So what’s kind of the basics is what you need just to get started with your pipe. So that’s if you want to talk like the absolute bare essentials, would say you need your pipes and when you buy a set of pipes often they come fully set up, but you can also get them what they call Sticks Only. Sticks Only is the three drones, the blowpipe, and five stocks.
So the three tenor stocks, the blowpipe stock and the chanter stock. That is Sticks Only and I do sell the R.G. Hardie Acetyl Bagpipes which are plastic or poly bagpipes. I have those in my shop, just put those up this week. Sticks Only that’s what you get, and that’s if you’re looking to have the lowest price point and to customize your pipes yourself for exactly how you want them. The next level up is what I call the Basics. In addition to the pipes, you need a pipe chanter, you need your reed, so you need a set of drone reeds and a pipe chanter reed.
You need a pipe bag, and then you need cords, the drone cords to hold your pipes together, that’s the absolute minimum that you need for a set of pipes that is playable. That’s the pipes with the pipe chanter, your drone reeds, your chanter reed, a bag and the drone cords. Now in addition to that there are some things that I recommend you’re going to want to get: a chanter cap for your pipe chanter. So when you’re not playing, you can pull it out.
And of course, you want to have the Tone Protector which is a humidity controlling chanter cap, which is my invention and my best selling product. I’m also going to recommend a moisture control system. My favorite is the Dri-flo. So the Dri-flo is canisters that go inside your bag and attach to the bottoms of your drone stocks. And what they do is they have silica gel, which is a desiccant, and it absorbs the moisture from your breath.
So as the air you blow into the bag travels through those desiccant canisters, the silica gel absorbs the moisture. And then by the time it gets to the end of the canister to your drone reed and to your drone, the air has been mostly dried out. So it’s nice and warm air. So I’m going to recommend the dri-flo system.
I’m also going to recommend my Tone Protector Reed Case. Get it for your backup pipe chanter reeds or some extra reeds. Maybe one you’ve already played that you still have kicking around that might have some more life in it. Or just some new reeds you haven’t played yet.
You’re going to want to have a roll of hemp. So black or yellow waxed hemp. A couple of the things that I like I recently released in my BagpipeLessons.com Precision Tuning Toolkit. So that has some things that are going to help you get your pipe chanter in shape. One of them is going to be your Piper’s Ultimate Reed Poker for opening up your reeds when they get too easy. It also comes with the elastic bridles for your pipe chanter reeds when they get too hard.
It comes with a roll of my favorite high performance black tuning tape that’s pre-cut to the half inch width. And it comes with a sanding pad, which you can use for sanding the blades of the reed when the reed is a little bit, needs to be freed up a little bit. And that’s often if you have a crowy top hand or if the reed just isn’t responding properly. So we’re just adding more and more things here to make your piping experience a little bit better.
Now, there are some additional tools that I really like. I released a product a few years ago, and it’s the Perfect Angle Blowpipe Positioner. What that does is it’s a system that you attach to your drone stocks and to your chanter stock, and there are a couple of straps that you can adjust. By adjusting the straps, you can angle your blowpipe so that it’s at the right angle, in the right position for your mouth. People who have these really love these. The reason they love it so much, and the reason I love it, is that it keeps your blowpipe right where you want it to be, and you don’t have to bite down on it.
As far as I know, correct me if I’m wrong, but I cannot think of another musical instrument where you’re required to hold something in your teeth. Now, there are other instruments where you might place it in your mouth, or you place it in your teeth, woodwind instruments, you know, you can think of like the harmonica. Those are in your mouth, but you’re holding them with your hand, and the blowpipe is the only thing I can think of where the pipers actually have to hold it with their teeth. If you let go, depending on your bag and your blowpipe and how things are set up, it can pop out. That’s a problem, because it means you have to bite down really hard to hold it in position.
So that’s why I came up with the Perfect Angle Blowpipe Positioner. I recommend this. Your jaw and your teeth will thank you for it. What it allows you to do is, when you take a breath, not only can you release your lips off the blowpipe, you can actually release your teeth. Sometimes after I’ve been playing a while, it just feels good to be able to take the mouth off and then go right back on. It’s right there.
So, also on my list of things, let’s see, brushes. You’re going to want to set up brushes. I have these in the shop. They’re these R.G. Hardie really nice cotton absorbing brushes in different sizes for swabbing out the inside of your stocks and your drones, your bass and tenor drones, the thin bore sections and the wider sections at the top. You want to have a set of brushes, because at some point or another, maybe sooner rather than later, you’re going to be getting moisture inside your pipes. My rule is that I never let moisture sit inside my pipes.
Now, if you’re in really challenging conditions, like if you’re playing a really long time and it’s cold, you get more condensation, or if you’re playing in the rain, your pipes will get wet on the outside, maybe on the inside. That’s unavoidable in certain situations. But my rule is, as soon as I’m done playing, all of that moisture comes out of the pipes. So if it’s a rainy day and it gets wet on the outside, I’m wiping off the exterior parts of my pipes completely, and then I’m using my brushes to brush everything out inside the chanter, if it’s really wet in there, inside all the stocks, if there’s any moisture in there. So you’re going to want to get some brushes.
And then I have three accessories that will make your life a lot easier. One is for tuning, and that’s my InTune Mic. That’s the wireless instrument microphone for your smartphone, one of my most popular products along with the Tone Protector and the Bagpipe Gauge. People love the InTune Mic because it lets you use these powerful tuning apps that you have on your phone for your bagpipes. It makes it real easy. You can have your phone sitting in front of you on a table, or connected with your Bagpipe Phone Mount and mounted right to your pipes so you can see it. The clip-on wireless mic allows you to tune your drones and tune your chanter really fast, with great precision, and it’s super easy.
I was just working with a band here in Seattle last night that I teach every Wednesday night, and I’m using my InTune Mic and my smartphone through the entire practice. It makes it really easy to tune drones. I’m just holding the phone in one hand, and then the clip-on mic goes onto a drone and I can tune it. Next drone, tune it up. To the bass, and I can tune it. I don’t have to be reaching way up with my phone and trying to get the microphone of the phone up to the drone. I can just be holding the phone comfortably in my hand, tuning the drone with the other hand, and the microphone is clipped on the top of the drone, positioned right above the drone.
You can tune in a completely noisy environment, like a pipe band situation, because the microphone placement is right next to what you’re trying to measure with the tuner. The problem with the phone is that the microphone is in the phone and the display is in the phone. So in order to be able to see it, you have to have it where you can see it with your eyes, but then the microphone needs to be right up against what you’re tuning. You can do that when you’re tuning someone else’s drones, just by holding the phone microphone right next to the top of the drone. The InTune Mic makes it really easy to tune chanters.
What I’ll do is I use the Braw Bagpipe Tuner and clip it onto somebody’s chanter. The way that the Braw Tuner works, different than any other tuner, is that it listens to all the notes that you’re playing continuously. You don’t have to play a note and look at the tuner. It’s just listening, and as it’s listening, it’s adjusting the display for every note on the chanter. Here’s an example of somebody from last night. They’re playing there, and you can see, if the note has a check mark on it, it’s in tune, right in the middle. If it’s to the right, it’s sharp. If it’s to the left, it’s flat. It has another display up top.
So I’ll just clip the InTune Mic onto somebody’s chanter and give it 30 seconds or a minute to listen. It’s adjusting all those little dots on the screen, and while I’m doing that, I can be doing something else. I can be going around listening to other people. I can be instructing the band. If you’re doing this yourself, you can just be playing.
You’re playing your tune, you’re practicing, you’re working on your stuff, and the mic is clipped onto your chanter and the tuner is listening. Then you can stop and go, “Oh, this is what I need to do. A couple of notes are sharp, maybe put a little bit of tape there. A couple of notes are flat, maybe take a little bit of tape off.” It works perfectly, even in a situation where you have a dozen bagpipers playing.
The secret is that the microphone is placed right up close to the one thing that you want to listen to. The way that I do it is I clip the mic behind the bottom of the pipe chanter, just behind the chanter, below where your thumb is on the back of the chanter. It seems to have a nice little pocket there between the chanter and the player’s body, and all that microphone hears is that one chanter. It works really, really great. Make your adjustments, and then I go and I move on to the next person.
I think what I need to do is make a video for the channel about how to tune a pipe band and show the whole process. But it’s as simple as getting a reading off the pipe major, or whoever you want to use as the foundation for your sound, and go, “Okay, that’s where we’re going to start.” Calibrate the tuner, hit all the drones real quick if the drones are really out, and then just go one player at a time and go around and use the Braw Tuner and make the adjustments.
At the band that I work with here in Seattle, what we’ve experimented with a little bit is having multiple phones and multiple InTune Mics. Ideally, you could have a phone and a mic for every single player, and every player just has their Braw Tuner going, maybe on a table in front of them or on a music stand, with the microphone clipped on.
Then the tuning person could go around and take a look at what the tuner is showing, make the adjustments as needed, and move around. Or you could have multiple people doing that. Or if your players are capable of making their own tuning adjustments, easy. Just play and play and play, and then you say, “Okay, everybody stop and make the adjustments that you need to,” and then you get your band in tune super fast.
The tuner eliminates the need to rely on your ear. You can still use your ear if you have a good one, but in a noisy situation like a pipe band, it’s really hard to pick out individual notes in the whole sound ecosystem, with all the different sounds. So it eliminates the need to trust your ear, and it also speeds up the process. Even when you’re really good at tuning with your ear, sometimes you get it wrong. You’ll hear that a note is out, and then you’ll think it’s sharp and you’ll flatten it, but it actually was flat. Trust me, even people who are really good at tuning will occasionally make the mistake of just going in the opposite direction.
Cool, so InTune Mic, I mentioned the Bagpipe Phone Mount. That’s what this looks like. It touches your blowpipe stock, and then you can mount your phone right on your blowpipe, and this is super fun for lots of different reasons. It’s great for tuning. You can see your tuner right here. You’re basically completely, not only wireless, but you’re completely mobile. So this is perfect if you’re at the Highland Games and you don’t have a music stand or a place to set your phone. You got your InTune Mic, clip to your pipes, you got your phone here, works great.
And then I also recommend my Bagpipe Gauge for learning to blow steady. I’ve got a new video coming out soon about the Bagpipe Gauge, but this is really the secret if you want to have a great sound. There’s a lot of things that go into having a great sound like tuning. The InTune Mic is for setup. So having a good set of drone reeds, having a good pipe chanter reed that is properly stored in your Tone Protector. But in addition to the skill of tuning and the equipment and the skill of setting up your equipment, the skill that you need to have a great sound is steady bag pressure.
So that’s where this Bagpipe Gauge works so well. You plug the stopper with the tube into one of your drones. I do the middle tenor, but you could do the outside tenor. You could do the bass. I typically don’t do the bass because if you cork off a drone, it doesn’t make sound. So corking off one of the tenors doesn’t affect the sound as much rather than the bass. And then this comes up a little strap that you can mount to your blowpipe as well with my deluxe strap. And you can just look at it right in your blowpipe. It does one incredibly powerful thing, which is it measures and displays the pressure inside your pipes.
If it’s wiggling back and forth, it means you need to be steadier. So the amount of movement, and how much the extremes of the movement will show you how steady you are. We call it steady blowing. It’s really a combination of blowing and squeezing with the arm, but really, ideally it would go to a specific number and it would hold it there. Now, if you look at the scale right in the middle there at the top, it says 30. That is 30 inches of water and that’s kind of in the green zone there. Most pipers are right around 30. I have used the gauge with hundreds of pipers over the years and I’d say 99% of pipers are in that green zone between 25 and 35.
Once you get over 35, if you like playing hard pipes like that, go for it. But most pipers I know, they’re suffering and they’re suffering in terms of their comfort and you also are going to be suffering in terms of how well you can play because you’re just working too hard. You’re blowing too hard, you’re squeezing too hard, and you lose your dexterity and it’s just overwhelming.
Check out the Bagpipe Gauge. It gives you two pieces of information. It shows you how steady you are and it gives you an exact reading of how hard your pipes are. A real common issue that we all face from time to time is something doesn’t feel right with our pipes and it can sometimes be a question of, is there something going on? Is there something wrong with my pipes or is it me?
And the first thing that I will ask a student who’s having issues, I’ll say, “Well, what does it say on the gauge?” And that’s the first thing to do because you want to know if the pressure is way off or, is the pressure in the range of where it should be? And if it’s in the range where it should be, then it could be that your pipes are taking too much air, meaning you have a leak.
So the pressure level is right, but you’re having to push too much air through those pipes because of the leak. Or it could be that there’s something going on with you physically, like you haven’t been playing enough and you’re a little bit out of shape. So that’s what the gauge is really good for. So that’s what I have sort of on my list. There are other gadgets as well but that’s what I have on the list for sets of pipes.
The absolute basics would be just getting a set of sticks. Then you need to add the drone cords, the pipe bag, and reeds to be playable. But then after that, there are other things that you are definitely going to want: your dri-flo moisture control system, your Tone Protector Reed Case, your Tone Protector Chanter Cap, you’re going to need some hemp and some brushes, and you’re probably going to want some things to get your pipes set up and tuned like my tuning toolkit with the poker and the elastics and the sander and the tape.
And you’re going to want my Bagpipe Gauge and the phone mount and the mic. So that’s kind of a bunch of my products, but that’s been what I’ve been doing over the years is figuring out the things that pipers struggle with. And these things are things that I’ve struggled with myself over the years and with my students and try to seek solutions to help pipers out. And then if it doesn’t exist, try to see if there’s something that I can come up with that’s helpful for me and helpful for my students.
The original Bagpipe Gauge was just something that I made a one-off trying to find the right gauge online and trying to find the tubing and trying to find a cork and trying to put it all together. And I encouraged my students. I said, “Well, here, I built one. You can build one.” And most of them wouldn’t do it. It’s too complicated to go and try to get all these parts.
Some of these are really hard specialty parts to find, like this little attachment here. So I said, “Okay, I’ll make a batch of them.” I made a batch of these Bagpipe Gauges. And they really loved them. And now I have them manufactured. And it’s a really cool, slick little package. And you can keep it right in your pipe case. Cool. Great question.
All right, Mark Lamont, been piping since ’99, from Chicago. Great. And you’re sharing what you play here. That is great. Officer Snap says, “I took your advice and rewound my practice chanter with waxed dental floss. Should I still get the roll of hemp?” If you’re still at the practice chanter stage, you don’t really need hemp at this point, if you’ve got your practice chanter with O-rings or with some dental floss on there. But you’re going to need some waxed hemp when it comes time to get those pipes, for sure.
All right, if you’re just joining us and you’re watching, pop a comment into the chat there. Tell us where you’re from and a little bit about your piping. We’d love to hear from you. So, all right, I got some questions here that have come through the website. This is a really common question that I get through the website.
I will email out some of my free guides and free information, and in one of the emails I ask, what are some of the greatest challenges that you face in your piping? This is a really common one: first, it’s hard for me to set aside the time to practice, with a full-time job that includes overtime and a family with kids and volunteering. It’s just trying to keep up with life. It gets difficult to make time for piping.
So if you feel that way, welcome. That means you are living a full and exciting life, and you’re definitely not bored. What I found over the years is that things change with work and family and travel and hobbies and other things that you’re involved with. I totally understand that. I’ve experienced that with my students, and it’s just okay to acknowledge that sometimes life gets in the way and there are other priorities, and that is totally okay.
Obviously family, work and other commitments can get in the way. But what I want to encourage you to do is to think about, and this is also a conversation to have if maybe it’s not an issue of time but an issue of motivation, or just trying to make use of the time: the important thing is to think about why you love piping.
Think about why you do it. Maybe you want to go back and think about the thing that originally inspired you to take up this instrument. What are the things that you love about being a piper? Maybe you want to compete. Maybe you’re part of a pipe band, and being part of that group and doing performances in the community is a big part of it.
Maybe this is just something that you do as a personal challenge. Maybe you have a connection to Scotland, and maybe that’s part of your heritage, or you just have an affinity for that part of Scottish culture. Think about what it is that inspires you and that motivates you. Bagpiping is fun, and it’s something that you do because you choose to do it. You don’t have to do it.
So just take a little bit of time to meditate on that and reflect on that, and maybe even take some notes. What I found is, if you’ve taken the time to reconnect with your inspiration and reflect on the things that you love about it, then automatically you’re going to be more excited about playing and more excited about practicing.
If there’s something that’s bugging you, maybe you’re bored with your tunes and you need a new tune, or maybe something isn’t right with your instrument, we’ve all been there. It’s really hard to find the enjoyment in playing when your instrument isn’t working right. If you need a new reed, or if there’s some maintenance that needs to be done, or maybe you need some new equipment, finding that thing that you love about it gives you that get-up-and-go and that inspiration to get back to it.
The other thing I would say is that maybe you can skip that whole thing about trying to get inspired, and you just commit. You just get back on the process and say, “Well, you know what, I’m going to commit to practicing four times a week.” So I get four days on, three days off every week, no more than two days off in a row, and I’m just going to commit to that for the next month and see how it goes.
I find there are things that are of a physical nature, like exercise. Maybe you’ve done some jogging before, or you used to go to the gym and you’re not doing it anymore, and it can be hard to get back into it. Sometimes we think that the inspiration needs to come first and then that drives the behavior, but I think there’s a lot of evidence that we can reverse that process.
Forget about feeling motivated or inspired for the minute, and just say, “I’m going to get going on the process. I’m going to get my routine going, and maybe how I feel about it will change.” I’ve certainly found that with a lot of things.
If you can just make a commitment to yourself and go, “I don’t have to do this forever, and if I don’t want to do it, I’m not going to force myself to do it, but I’m going to make a short-term commitment to see how I feel after a week or three or four weeks of just doing it, and doing a little bit every day for four or five days a week,” try that. There are certain things, physical things, athletic things, exercise things, and bagpiping certainly has this physical component to it, that it just doesn’t feel great until you get your motor going and get those muscles going.
And then finally, if you’re talking about trying to fit it into a busy life, there’s a saying which is, if you want to get something done and you need to ask someone for help, ask a busy person, because they know how to get things done and they know how to be efficient with their time. I certainly have found that having a family and having lots of things going on in my personal and my business life, I can still get a lot done, but I just have to be more organized and proactive about it.
It’s kind of a life skill thing, but this is definitely something that I’m trying to set an example for my kids with, and something that I teach them through example and also explicitly, which is to take control of your time and to take control of your attention, so that the most important things in your life get the time and attention that they want.
We live in a time where there are more distractions now than there have ever been in the history of humanity, because we have the entire world of technology available to us right here on your phone or on your computer. So the person who wants to live a life where they are setting the direction for their life, part of that is to be proactive and to persist in the things, and take the time to be organized and set aside time for the things you want to do, but also to intentionally resist and avoid distractions.
That’s a big thing. Think about every day: what are the most important things that I want to accomplish today, or this week, or this month, or in the next 12 weeks? And make sure that you’re setting aside time for the important things.
I love it when I’m teaching young people, teenagers especially, and they tell me that they’re too busy for piping. They love piping and they want to pipe, they’re studying with me, it’s important to them and to their parents to invest in this part of their education, but they’re too busy. I love that conversation, because it opens up this discussion of, okay, well, let’s talk about the things that you’re doing.
It might be the first time that that young person is having this realization that if I’m going to be able to do this thing which is important to me, I’m going to have to make some sacrifices and be more intentional with how I spend my time. So, for example, I will ask, how many hours this week did you spend playing video games?
I’m not a fan of video games. That’s just my thing. Some people love them and find them relaxing. I just personally think they’re a big colossal waste of time, and I would rather spend my time practicing my pipes and spending time with my kids, doing other things rather than getting immersed in this digital world. That’s your personal choice.
But if you are finding it challenging to get the motivation or to find the time to do your piping, take a look at how you’re spending your time. Try to find if there are things about your piping that you can focus on that are more inspiring and motivating to you. Or skip that step and just say, “Okay, I’m going to schedule this into my weekly schedule.” If you’ve got 15 or 20 minutes four times a week or more, you’re rolling. I often find that if you schedule a short session, you’re more likely to do it, and often when you get going on that short session, you want to keep going once you’re over the hump. Cool. Great question.
All right, so we’ve got more stuff in the chat. Officer Snap is from Huntsville. Fantastic, have some friends down there. I have never been down there. Matthew said, “Piping since Thanksgiving Day 2000.” Great. I didn’t know that, Matt. That’s cool. It’s a very specific day. That’s excellent. LEO is from Montrose, BC, Canada. Cool. Great. So Mark says, “I thought solo piping was the end all, be all, until I attended my first band rehearsal. Then I was hooked. Listening to the roll-offs and the drone striking in is awesome.”
I agree. I mean, I love the sound of a solo bagpipe. I have to say, I agree with you that when you are in a band and you have that visceral experience of being in that group and having all those bagpipes kicking in together, it’s just an amazing sound. I played in the SFU pipe band for 19 years as one of the world’s top bands, and won the world championships with them. A lot of great things about the band.
Great friends, fun experiences, tremendously challenging and engaging fun tunes, cool arrangements, but I got to say right at the top is the experience of playing in that circle with 20 to 30 bagpipers all playing at that world-class level, pipes, chanters all in tune, and it takes a lot of work and there’s a lot of moving parts to get that band to be at that level of cohesion and unison of playing and tuning. But when it happens, it’s just an amazing experience. So you can experience that at every level, but certainly for me playing in SFU for all those years was absolutely one of the peak experiences that I’ve had as a musician.
Something I looked forward to each year were those performances, where the tone and the playing all came together. We won the Worlds in 2008 and 2009 and I remember coming off and the player next to me, I mean it’s a very emotional experience, it’s a lot of pressure, so you can think about it like sports highlights, like a tennis match. There’s just so much concentration and tension, and then the player hits that final point, and then they win and they collapse. It’s like that kind of feeling, it’s a huge relief and a sense of accomplishment and it’s just a very emotional experience after all that tension. Then it’s instantly over.
So it’s a very similar feeling at the Worlds. You have this performance, you’ve been leading up to it for the whole year, maybe for your whole career, it’s an amazing experience. Then you come off and I remember feeling that sense of emotion and excitement especially when it’s one of the greatest performances you’ve ever been a part of. The piper standing next to me was just overcome with emotion and he said, “I just never thought that I would play, I just never thought I would play like this, that it could sound that good.” So it’s just an amazing experience. And regardless of what level you’re at, you have that ability to, when you’re in a band, to push yourself and to have that amazing communal experience.
I think that’s one of the best things about playing in a band, is you do have that team to rely on and you have that team that is relying on you. So they are supporting you, but you also need to do your part. So in that way, it can be very inspiring and motivating because you want to be a good team player and you want to be a contributor and you want to be a person that raises the level of the band and that can be tremendously fun and inspiring to be part of that.
Yeah, Mark says, “It’s like winning the Stanley Cup.” Yeah, I mean, it’s to play in the Worlds. It’s a great experience to play in the Worlds at the grade one level and be in a winning band. It’s fantastic. You never forget it. But I don’t think about it every day. I don’t have any trophies or medals displayed in my house. I know some people do. Those are great memories, and I’m very proud of those accomplishments, but I don’t need them hanging around my house. Also, don’t hang my college diploma up, either. It’s in a box somewhere. That’s just my thing.
OK, Officer Snap, “Which is your favorite of the starter tunes and which gave you the most trouble?” Wow. OK, that’s going way back for me. My first tune was ‘Scots Wha Hey,’ 6-8 Slow Air from the College of Piping Green Book. I think that’s a fantastic tune. I teach that as the first tune. The second tune that I teach is ‘Going Home,’ which is another 6-8 Slow Air. Hard for me to remember which gave me the most trouble in terms of tune, but I do remember the hardest thing for me when I was learning to play was the bottom hand and the thumb. So I remember it was like my first or second lesson.
I just remember having this pain in this thumb here. Now, I was a kid when I started, and I was a pretty small kid. I was the smallest kid in my class in school. Had a little bit of a growth spurt later, but I have had small hands, and I remember just really having pain in this thumb muscle here on the bottom hand, and that is very common. I actually remember being in tears. Part of it was sitting at my parents’ kitchen table with the chanter maybe up like this in a strange angle. So you want to have the chanter sort of vertical-ish, rest on a table or a counter that’s fine, maybe you rested on your knee, maybe you’re just holding it, but you don’t want to be up here like this.
I’ll sometimes see people that they rest their forearms on a table and they’re doing that terrible, terrible idea. You want to try to play in a neutral position. This is how the pipes are going to be, where your forearms are parallel to the ground, or maybe slightly down, not up and not way down. So you want to try to replicate that with your practice chanter. Obviously the practice chanter is maybe a little bit higher than the pipes, but ish, close ish.
So I would say if your hand’s, if your thumb’s hurting, that’s normal, but you want to try to keep those hands soft, keep them as soft as you can. If you’ve been following my teaching, you’ve heard me talk about the two pillars of good technique, of good bagpipe form. And that is keeping your hands as relaxed and loose and soft as possible, right? So the opposite of being tight or stiff or rigid or squeezing, we want to get rid of all that. And I have condensed that down to one word and that is ‘soft.’ You want to have soft hands on the chanter.
I’ve heard people say, “Oh, you want it to be like you’re holding a full tube of toothpaste and you’re just squeezing it just enough so that you can see that little bit of toothpaste coming out of the top.” Or I heard a kid at a workshop say, “My teacher says, it’s like you’re holding a baby bird. Just, you don’t want to squish it, but you don’t want it to get away.” OK, those are all fine analogies. The way I think about it is you want to just have the absolute minimum amount of pressure needed to cover the holes.
And for most pipers, most of the time we have too much pressure, right? So the chanter doesn’t change a sound if you squeeze too hard. That’d be a cool invention if you had that. If somehow you would get an auditory signal that, “Oh, I’m squeezing too tight.” So instead what you have to rely on is your own sense of pressure. And what I would recommend is you go back to playing something really, really soft, or sorry, really, really easy, and just try to relax your hands as much as possible. You know, just even playing the low G or playing a scale and see if you can relax your hands.
And eventually, your fingers will slip off the holes, but until you get to that point, you can go softer. So soft hands, that’s number one. And then the second pillar of good form is to keep them low. We don’t need to lift our fingers really high. We just keep them nice and low. Now you will see pipers who raise their fingers high and even really good pipers, but it’s not needed and it slows you down. On a long note, you can do whatever you want. On a long note, you can lift those fingers high. It doesn’t help you, but it doesn’t really, it’s not as important.
And on short notes, they have to be really, really close to the chanter. There’s just no way to play these quick 16th notes and 32nd notes and cut them the way that we like to in our pipe tunes if you are lifting your fingers really high off the chanter. So soft and low. Those are the things you want to do. Low and soft. Great. All right, great comments in here.
Mark Lamont says, “Watch a video of John D. Burgess. His hands are softly on his chanter. Amazing player who’s considered the first real piping prodigy.” I agree with the first part. Two comments, not so much on the third one. John D. Burgess was an absolutely fantastic player. I knew him in his later days. He was past his playing days. But I remember he judged me a few times in Scotland. Fantastic person and a real character.
Just think of these glamorous movie stars of the past generations. He was like that. He was a true star of piping. And his personality, he backed it up with his track record. He won the gold medal in Scotland, which is the top prize at age 16. So he was a true prodigy. I don’t think he was the first one. There’s certainly one of the great talents of the piping world. And there’s a fantastic video of Burgess playing. If you just look up John D.
Burgess, Seamus McNeil. And those are two great characters of piping. And I think there’s a BBC or some television program. And it’s John Burgess playing pipes. And there’s two things, multiple things about it. It’s a masterclass in how to play with ease. So I mean, it just barely looks like he’s blowing bubbles in milk with his blowpipe. Drones don’t move. Everything is just really still. And then the fingers hardly coming off the chanter.
So that’s the gold standard right there to not only look like it’s easy, but to actually have it be easy. So when you watch that, it’s like, wow. He makes it look easy. Well, I would argue that it looks easy because it is easy for him. So how can you do something like play the bagpipe and have it be easy? Well, practice getting in shape, but also doing things properly. And that goes right back to your early stages or wherever you are in your piping career and practicing in a way which you play with a lot of ease.
Keep the hands soft, keep them low, make sure your pipes are optimized so that they’re as efficient as possible. I think when you watch a great athlete, like Roger Federer, one of the great tennis players, he just had so much smoothness and finesse with his playing. Obviously he’s an insanely powerful athlete. And you say, “Well, it just looks easy for him.” And I think certain things that he could do that were exceptionally difficult were easy for him because he’d optimized his technique and because he’d practiced it, right?
There’s a lot going on when you’re playing the pipes. We have the fingering, we have the technique, we have the timing, we have our tempo, we’re marching around, we’re blowing our pipes. There’s multiple things going on and it’s impossible to focus on all of them. But in order to be good, all those things have to be good, even when you’re not thinking about them. So how can you play a good birl without thinking about it? How can you keep a steady bag pressure when you’re not thinking about it?
How can you keep a steady tempo when you’re thinking about something else? Well, the way we do that is by practicing things properly and getting enough reps and enough practice that it’s good enough on its own. So it requires you to get automatic so that these things just happen on their own. So you can think, “Oh, what’s the next tune that’s going to be coming up here? Oh yeah.” And when you have that thought about the next tune, that your hands don’t just fall off the chanter or that you forget to blow.
In the early stages, you have to think about the blowing. And I’ve seen this with students when they go from the practice chanter and they transition to the pipes, you have to think about blowing and squeezing and all the mechanics of it because you’re new to it. But then what happens when you’ve practiced it enough, it becomes automatic. And if you read about the theories of motor learning and blowing your pipes or playing a birl, these are all motor skills. There’s three stages. The first stage is where you have to think about every step and you’re using words and rules and it’s the verbal stage.
And then the final stage is the autonomous stage where these things happen automatically. The middle stage is called the associative stage where you’re kind of in between, you’re thinking a little bit about it, but some of it’s automatic. So that’s how you do it. You work on all these things separately and your skills get better and they become more optimized and they’re more consistent. And then eventually they become autonomous.
So another way to think about it, it’s like in the cartoons where the cartoon character is tempted in making a decision, and there’s a little angel and little devil that sort of pop up on their shoulders. And it’s as if the angel and devil, they’re like two little characters inside that person’s mind or their soul, kind of like pulling them in each direction. Well, it’s almost like you could think about each one of these skills that you’re doing at the same time, they’re like little characters.
It’s like, “Oh, well, here’s the little birl, little character, and then here’s the blowing character and here’s what tune comes next character.” So there’s all these little entities. This is all hypothetical sort of metaphoric here, but it’s as if they’re these little entities and you train each one. When you practice, “I’m going to work on my blowing. I’m going to work on my blowing. I’m going to work on my squeezing. I’m going to work on my birls. I’m going to work on my memorization.”
And you focus on that thing with the goal that when you’re playing, and when you can think about one thing, and you’re blowing or your birls, or your crossing noises, or your memorization, that those little elements, that they do the right thing even when you’re not with them, even when you’re shining the spotlight of your attention somewhere else, that you’ve practiced them properly and sufficiently so that they do what they’re supposed to do automatically.
OK, let’s keep looking here. “Yeah, well, your pipe should be easy for you to play.” That’s a direct quote from Malcolm McCrae, who’s an Australian piper who lived in Scotland for many years. Top prize winner, respected judge. And at a piobaireachd workshop that I was at with Malcolm years ago, he said the exact words, “Your pipes should be easy for you.” And what that means is that you want to have them optimized. There’s a lot of things that go into that. So you can watch my YouTube video called “Why Are My Pipes So Hard?”
There’s lots of reasons your pipes can be hard. But if they’re easy for you, everything has to be right. Sizing, blowpipe, sizing of bag, proper drone reeds, good drones, drone reeds optimized, adjusted, pipe chanter reed with the Tone Protector. So it’s got the right amount of moisture, the right strength. It’s a good reed. It’s efficient. It’s been broken in. And you, you have to be in shape. You can give a perfect set of pipes to someone, absolute optimized pipes. But if you’re not in shape and you’re rusty or your physicality isn’t there, it’s not going to work.
So you have to be in shape. Your pipes have to be dialed in. You’re working together. Your pipes should be easy for you. That’s the secret. So you look at a top player and they’re just busting out complicated tunes or the most beautiful piobaireachd with every note just perfectly dialed in. How do they do that? A lot of practice, but they’re probably in the zone. They’re feeling comfortable. Everything is dialed in. They’re not struggling and hoping, right?
I read a very interesting book a couple months ago, and it was written by a former Google data scientist who’s obsessed with basketball, sports in general. And he looked at all the statistics, like the entire statistical record for the National Basketball Association, our professional league here, and did all this data analysis on it. And the book is called “Who Makes the NBA?” All kinds of really interesting statistics about height and hand size and different physical attributes that they measure and what is predictive of success and sociological factors.
Is it an advantage to be from a certain background? Is it an advantage to have a father that played in the NBA? All kinds of really interesting statistics. Well, one thing that he looked at was the ability to perform under pressure. So the ability to perform under pressure would be, in basketball, what’s your shooting percentage in the last couple of minutes of a game when it’s within five points? And they compare that to every other time. So they can define what’s a high-pressure clutch situation based on the score and how close it is to the end of the game.
And then they look at how well a player does there compared to everything else. And this was an amazing statistic to me. They found that zero players are better in the clutch. That they found no NBA player who is better under pressure than when they’re not under pressure. They found some players that were the same. And those were the great players. The great players are the ones that whatever their shooting accuracy is throughout their whole career, when it gets to the crunch time at the end of a game, under pressure when it’s close, they’re the same.
Nobody gets better. Most people get worse. They are not as good under pressure when the game is on the line. So that is a really interesting statistic to me. And that matches with my experience, which is, if you are in a competition scenario, you should not expect that you’re going to do better when it really matters.
Like if it’s a big competition, it’s the gold medal, it’s the World’s, maybe it’s just a performance you’re doing. It’s a non-competitive performance but you really want it to be good, do not expect that it’s going to be better than what you’ve been doing before when you’re not under pressure. So that informs us if you want to do well when it really matters, you need to be doing well in the days and weeks and months leading up to it.
So in SFU we had the saying “cruise and win” and “cruise and win” means you have to be at that level of performance to win going into the thing. Don’t expect it. “Oh gosh, we’re getting close now, it’s going to get great at the end.” It just doesn’t happen. It doesn’t happen to elite basketball players. It’s not going to happen to you.
All right, we’re getting close to the end here. “What is the simplest definition of piobaireachd?” Great question. So piobaireachd is a Gaelic word which literally translated means “bagpipe music.” But we refer to it as a type of bagpipe music in which the tunes are long, maybe five or seven minutes up to 20, 25 minutes. And they consist of a theme and variations. The theme is typically quite slow and involves a lot of nuanced phrasing and expression. And then with each variation, it has the same basic melody that you heard in the ground. And you represent those melody notes in a slightly different way with a different rhythmic context, different embellishments and gracenoting, and a different tempo.
So there are tunes that have a ground in one variation. Typical would be a tune with a ground and maybe between five and 10 variations. There are tunes that have even more, maybe up to 20 variations. So a variation might be a taorluath variation. So you play all of the notes that came across in the theme in the ground, but then you play them with a taorluath on each note.
Or a crunluath variation, which would be your melody notes with crunluath. There’s a variation called a dithis variation where it’s your theme note and a short low A. There’s a siubhal variation where you play your theme note and then a higher note. There’s a really cool variation in a tune called ‘Fair Honey,’ where you have your theme notes and in between each one you have a jili, which is a high A doubling. So there’s all kinds of really cool different types of variations.
These piobaireachd tunes are still being written, but many of them are quite ancient, hundreds and hundreds of years old. A lot of our great tunes came from the McCrimmons who are on Skye and the McCrimmon family. They were the hereditary pipers to the McClouds and for many generations they had a piping school up on Skye and wrote a lot of these fantastic piobaireachd tunes. There’s still new tunes being written.
This book came out a couple years ago, the Shasta Collection. And this was a compilation of the tunes that were submitted to a tune writing competition. And I wrote a few of the winning tunes. The first one I wrote was for my teacher, Colin McKenzie. It’s me and Colin, and it’s ‘Colin McKenzie’s Salute.’ So written in the old style, I didn’t try to make them sound particularly modern. I wanted to try to write a tune that was in the style of the classic piobaireachd. I’m not sure on the exact number of piobaireachds that we have, but in terms of that canon of tunes, excluding the modern piobaireachds, I think we have probably 250 to 300.
So really, really cool. And it’s not everybody’s cup of tea, but the pipers who love playing piobaireachd, they really love it. I think some of them might disagree with me, but I think it’s some of the most challenging and most interesting and most satisfying music to play because of the subtlety and the expression that you get to put into it. So if you want to look up some tunes, some great tunes that I recommend you look up, one would be ‘The Lament for the Children,’ ‘The Lament for Donald Dougal Mackay,’ ‘I Got a Kiss of the King’s Hand,’ ‘The Lament for Patrick Ogg McCrimmon,’ one of the all-time greats, it really features this high G note, which is a very mournful note.
And some beginner piobaireachds, the first tunes that I usually teach people, is a tune called ‘The Munro’s Salute.’ Another tune is called ‘The Little Spree.’ ‘The Munro’s Salute’ and ‘The Little Spree’ I have for download in my shop. It’s a tune lesson download, you get the sheet music, recording of me playing the tune, and also a recorded lesson of me talking through the tune. I also have in my shop a lesson, it’s actually recorded of a masterclass that I gave on one of my all-time favorite tunes called ‘Too Long in this Condition.’ ‘Too Long’ is also on my album Bagpipe Revolution. And I did it as a duet through multi-tracking.
I recorded the melody part, and I recorded a harmony part for it. And I really love that track because it’s something that I’d always wanted to do, which was to play a piobaireachd and then record a harmony part with it, and get the harmonies really, really tight. You get some really cool sort of sonic kind of effects with the full rich lush sound of the bagpipe played in harmony. So you have two chanters going and six drones going.
Mark Lamont throws in the comments, “A ‘Flame of Wrath’ is awesome.” Yeah, ‘A Flame of Wrath for Squinting Patrick,’ fantastic tune. That one is one of the most aggressive rhythmic and driving tunes, really matches the title, ‘Flame of Wrath.’ Great. Excellent. Thanks, everybody. Thanks for joining in and for putting in the comments. This is really fun. I’m going to keep doing this. I’ve got a little bit of traveling later in the summer. But when I’m around, and if I can get to it from the road, I will. I’ll flip on YouTube, and we’ll have a little conversation. Check out my YouTube channel, BagpipeLessons.com. I’m posting videos all the time.
We’re doing long videos, live videos, and doing shorts. Every day we’re posting new shorts. Check out my social media channels on Instagram and Facebook, BagpipeLessons.com. And if you like this information and you want more of it, I do live classes every week on Zoom. And you can join me live with the other members of my BagpipeLessons.com Inner Circle. Check that out at BagpipeLessons.com/membership. And of course, there’s my shop, BagpipeLessons.com/shop with all the Tone Protectors and the toolkits and Bagpipe Gauges and all that stuff. Let’s be in touch. Thanks, everybody. Hope your summer is going great, and we will see you next time. Thanks, everybody. Mahalo.
My exact words from the video, lightly cleaned up for reading. Click any time to jump the video to that moment.

Ready to take your piping further?
Get unlimited access to 790+ lessons, videos and tunes, plus a live Zoom class with me every week. Every replay is searchable to the exact moment anything was taught.


