Live Answers to Your Bagpipe Questions — Ergonomics, Bag Size, Blowpipe Length, Seven Birl & More - Ergonomics
▶ Video lessonLive Q&AJori Chisholm, BagpipeLessons.com. Updated April 27, 2024

Live Answers to Your Bagpipe Questions — Ergonomics, Bag Size, Blowpipe Length, Seven Birl & More

Your pipes should fit your body. Most pipers do well with a small bag, because a bigger bag is harder to get up under your arm. Blowpipes that are too long and bags that are too large are the most common problems. In this live Q&A I also cover the seven birl and how I break in reeds.

The Main Ideas

In this live Q&A I answer questions you emailed me. The big one is ergonomics: how to choose a pipe bag size and a blowpipe length so your pipes fit your body.

I explain why most pipers do well with a small bag, what the Willie McCallum size is for, and what to do if your arms are long. Then I cover the seven birl, where your thumb goes, and how I break in reeds with the Tone Protector Reed Case.

If you want to go further on the birl, my Bagpipe Essentials Masterclass has a full video on it.

At a glance

Two things you can sizeThe pipe bag and the blowpipe
Most popular bag sizesSmall, extended small and the Willie McCallum size
My default recommendationA small bag, even if you are tall
If your arms are longA bag with extra neck length
Blowpipe testFilm yourself playing and check your head, neck and forearms
Seven birlTouch, slide down, slide up and pull back
Thumb positionBetween the middle and ring fingers

Video highlights

“The idea of ergonomics is to find a way that you can work with your equipment and your body in the most biomechanically friendly way.”
“But the basic idea is you have a body. You use your body to play your instrument.”
“Most top pipers have it in the exact same spot right in between the middle and the ring finger. That’s the secret spot.”
“That’s the biggest secret, I can say, in terms of having reeds that sound good, feel good, stay in tune, last a long time, are efficient to play, and have very little break in time.”
Find Your Perfect Pipe Bag Size
Free guideFind Your Perfect Pipe Bag SizeMy free guide to choosing a pipe bag size that fits you, building on the ergonomics we talk about in this video.
Get the free guide

The gear and courses in this video

Your questions, answered

Tap a time to watch that part of the video.

Which pipe bag do you recommend?

The Bannatyne Hybrid bags. They are high quality, last a long time and are great value. The bag is hard and airtight when full, with no give or sponginess, which helps you keep a steady pressure. Willie McCallum suggested I try one almost 20 years ago.

What size pipe bag should I get for my height?

If you are 5'7" or shorter, go with a small. I know people well over six feet tall who play a small and love it. A smaller bag is quicker to fill, easier to deflate on cutoffs, and you can get it higher up under your arm.

What is the Willie McCallum size pipe bag?

Willie worked with Bannatyne on a custom bag. The back is closer to a medium, but the front, where your arm goes, tapers more like an extended small. So you can still get it high in your armpit without the bag pressing on your forearm.

Are there pipe bags for kids or very small pipers?

For my son I worked with Bannatyne on a custom super small bag. Other instruments have fractional sizes, but bagpipes do not. A bag that fits you is the thing you can change, so if you are a smaller person, go with the small.

What if the distance from the drones to my chanter is too short for my arms?

This happens with people who have longer arms. They feel scrunched even when the bag feels great under the arm. I had Bannatyne make an extended small with extra length added to the neck. The student who gave me the idea says it is the most comfortable bag he has ever played.

How do I know if my blowpipe is the right length?

Look at top pipers. Their forearms are horizontal or just a little down, while amateurs often have them way down. If your head turns away or you are craning your neck forward or back, your blowpipe may be too long. Film yourself from all angles to check.

Is there an adjustable length blowpipe?

Yes. I sell the AdjustiStick, made by R.G. Hardie. It has a great valve built inside and a telescoping length. The R.G. Hardie Poly bagpipes come with one. Try one for a week or two, then you will know the length that suits you.

What blowpipe works for kids or short pipers?

John Walsh has an adjustable length blowpipe for kids that gets really short. If you are 5'5" or shorter, it is a great option, because at its shortest length you can find your sweet spot.

Does it matter how far down the chanter hangs?

Yes, thanks to Donna for that great point. The chanter stock is an open sleeve, so you can set it deeper or let it hang out more. Put your hands where they feel most comfortable, then check whether your chanter is at that height.

Which birl should I learn?

I recommend the seven birl, and it is the one I play. You touch the chanter, slide down, and pull back. It is harder to learn at first, but it is way more reliable, especially for birls from B, C and low G.

How can I practice the range of motion for the seven birl?

Keep three fingers in position and let the pinky go down. You can practice on the knuckle of your other fist, with a rubber band around your hand, or on a tabletop, where you push down the way you do on the chanter.

Why does my ring finger move when I birl?

I have never met anybody who can pull the pinky in without moving the ring finger. That is okay, as long as the ring finger does not come off the hole. Keep your hands as relaxed as possible to minimize it.

Where should my bottom hand thumb go on the chanter?

Most top pipers place it right between the middle and the ring finger. If your thumb is higher, moving it will feel odd for a week or two. It helps you keep the ring finger in position and everything balanced.

What is the best way to break in chanter reeds?

Most of the struggle is really getting the reed to the right moisture level. I was amazed how much work the Tone Protector Reed Case does. Pair it with a good reed, and store the reed there so it does not dry out.

Each week, the Inner Circle's lively sessions are designed to benefit pipers of all skill levels, all around the world.

LEARN FASTER. FIND GREATER ENJOYMENT FROM YOUR PIPING. JOIN ME.

Join the Inner Circle

Full video transcript

My exact words from the video, lightly cleaned up for reading. Click any time to jump the video to that moment.

Jori Chisholm, founder of BagpipeLessons.com
About Jori Chisholm

Jori started BagpipeLessons.com in 1999, and in 2003 he became the first piper to teach one-on-one lessons by video. His online teaching has been featured on the front page of the New York Times, and thousands of pipers around the world have used his lessons, tools and products.

He is a four-time U.S. Gold Medalist for Piping, has won prizes at the Argyllshire Gathering, the Northern Meeting, Cowal and Braemar, and won the World Pipe Band Championships three times with the Simon Fraser University Pipe Band. He invented the Tone Protector, the InTune Mic and the Endurance Practice Chanter, and in 2011 he founded the World Online Piping & Drumming Championships.

More about Jori →
Jori Chisholm holding a practice chanter
The Inner Circle

Ready to take your piping further?

Get unlimited access to 790+ lessons, videos and tunes, plus a live Zoom class with me every week. Every replay is searchable to the exact moment anything was taught.

$399/year works out to $33.25 a month$45/month month to month
For pipe bandsBring your whole band into the Inner Circle Every piper gets their own login, and we start with a band coaching session on Zoom with me to map out your season. From $10 per piper per month.See band memberships →
Free: Find Your Perfect Pipe Bag SizeGet it