LIVE Q&A: World Championships, Tone Protector Success, and Top Piping Tips - BagpipeLessons.com
▶ Video lessonLive Q&AJori Chisholm, BagpipeLessons.com. Updated September 16, 2024

LIVE Q&A: World Championships, Tone Protector Success, and Top Piping Tips

A summer catch-up on the World Pipe Band Championships and the top solo events at Oban and Inverness, plus my answers on muscle memory, favorite slow airs and tapping your foot. Muscle memory is for short movements that are always the same. Get them slow and correct before you speed them up, because practice makes permanent.

The Main Ideas

In this live Q&A I catch up on what happened in piping over the summer. Inverary & District won Grade 1 at the World Pipe Band Championships, my old band SFU finished in the top three, and pipers using the Tone Protector did very well at Oban and Inverness.

Then I answer viewer questions. What is muscle memory and how do you build it? Why does practice make permanent, not perfect? What is my favorite slow air? And should you tap your foot when you play?

I also tell you about a new video I am working on, on blowpipe ergonomics, after a great chat with Dr. Gord Pollock, a piper and dentist.

At a glance

World Pipe Band ChampionshipsInverary & District won Grade 1. My old band SFU finished in the top three
Top solo eventsThe Argyllshire Gathering at Oban and the Northern Meeting at Inverness
Tone Protector at Oban33 of the placings in the top events went to pipers using it
Muscle memoryFor short movements that are always the same, like a D throw or a birl
How to build itLearn it properly and slowly first, then speed up and add reps
My go-to slow airsScots Wha Hae and Going Home
Foot tappingTap your foot all the way through. Start with low A and B
New video comingErgonomics and the blowpipe, with Dr. Gord Pollock

Video highlights

“Because the memory is not in your muscles. The memory is in your brain.”
“Because as you play things over and over, they don’t tend to get better. They tend to get more permanent.”
“Practice doesn’t make perfect. Practice makes permanent.”
“I think bagpipe music, because it is so rhythmic and we want to have a nice steady tempo: use your foot. It works.”
How to Achieve a World-Class Bagpipe Sound
Free guideHow to Achieve a World-Class Bagpipe SoundIf you enjoyed hearing about the top players at the Worlds, Oban and Inverness, this free guide is about getting a world-class sound from your own pipes.
Get the free guide

The gear and tunes in this video

Your questions, answered

Tap a time to watch that part of the video.

Who won Grade 1 at the World Pipe Band Championships?

Congratulations to Inverary & District. The Worlds is a huge event with hundreds of pipe bands from around the world. It is sort of the Super Bowl for bagpipe bands.

Can I watch the World Pipe Band Championships online?

Yes. The BBC films the Worlds and you can watch for free. In the UK you can watch live on the day, and the rest of the world gets the replay. I put the links in the video description.

Which pipe band was the first to use the Tone Protector?

My old band, the Simon Fraser University Pipe Band. They were the first band in the world to use it, going back seven years, and the Tone Protector came out in 2017. They finished in the top three.

What are the most prestigious solo piping competitions?

The Argyllshire Gathering at Oban and the Northern Meeting at Inverness. They go back a couple hundred years, you have to apply to get in, and they are limited to about 75 pipers or fewer than a hundred.

Do top competitors use the Tone Protector?

Yes. A lot of the world’s top players use it. Nick Hudson, who won the Clasp at Inverness, has eight Tone Protectors in his pipe case: seven on chanters, plus the Tone Protector Reed Case.

How did Tone Protector users do at Oban and Inverness?

At Oban, 33 of the placings in the top events were won by pipers using the Tone Protector. At the Northern Meeting, Nick Hudson won the Gold Clasp. The players deserve all the credit. It takes as much time and dedication as a second job.

What is the Glenfiddich Invitational?

It is the year-end invitational contest at Blair Castle in Scotland. They invite the first place winners from the top competitions of the preceding year, including the Gold Medal winners and the winner of the Glenfiddich from the year before.

Can the blowpipe cause jaw and teeth problems for pipers?

Yes. Dr. Gord Pollock, a piper and dentist, filled me in on chipped teeth, sore jaw, and head and neck pain. Your jaw moves with two joints, so it causes problems if it gets pushed to the side or has unequal pressure.

What is muscle memory and how do I build it?

The memory is in your brain, but we use the term for a short movement that is always the same, like a D throw or a birl. To build it, learn the movement properly and slowly first, then gradually speed it up and do more reps.

What is your favorite slow air?

My go-to when I am teaching is Scots Wha Hae, then Going Home. I also love Angus G. McCloud, which is on my Bagpipe Revolution album, and I often play the South Georgia Whaling Song to warm up for light music events.

Should I tap my foot when I play, and for the whole tune?

Yes, I recommend it. Bagpipe music is very rhythmic, with a steady tempo, so your foot helps you build a steady beat. Tap all the way through the tune. If your foot goes haywire in one part, that part needs work.

What is unusual about the South Georgia Whaling Song?

It is in 6-8 and mixes the typical dot-cut triplets with really even triplets. That is unusual in a slow air, and those even ones give it a really cool sound.

Each week, the Inner Circle's lively sessions are designed to benefit pipers of all skill levels, all around the world.

LEARN FASTER. FIND GREATER ENJOYMENT FROM YOUR PIPING. JOIN ME.

Join the Inner Circle

Full video transcript

My exact words from the video, lightly cleaned up for reading. Click any time to jump the video to that moment.

Jori Chisholm, founder of BagpipeLessons.com
About Jori Chisholm

Jori started BagpipeLessons.com in 1999, and in 2003 he became the first piper to teach one-on-one lessons by video. His online teaching has been featured on the front page of the New York Times, and thousands of pipers around the world have used his lessons, tools and products.

He is a four-time U.S. Gold Medalist for Piping, has won prizes at the Argyllshire Gathering, the Northern Meeting, Cowal and Braemar, and won the World Pipe Band Championships three times with the Simon Fraser University Pipe Band. He invented the Tone Protector, the InTune Mic and the Endurance Practice Chanter, and in 2011 he founded the World Online Piping & Drumming Championships.

More about Jori →
Jori Chisholm holding a practice chanter
The Inner Circle

Ready to take your piping further?

Get unlimited access to 790+ lessons, videos and tunes, plus a live Zoom class with me every week. Every replay is searchable to the exact moment anything was taught.

$399/year works out to $33.25 a month$45/month month to month
For pipe bandsBring your whole band into the Inner Circle Every piper gets their own login, and we start with a band coaching session on Zoom with me to map out your season. From $10 per piper per month.See band memberships →
Free: How to Achieve a World-Class Bagpipe SoundGet it
WATCH More Videos

▶ Video Chapters

Tap a time to jump the video there.